3 Key Things the Class of 2026 Should Consider When Building a College List
At Miller College Counseling, we don’t follow trends—we anticipate them. With a 100% acceptance rate, we rely on real-time data and years of experience to help students create a college list that is strategic, balanced, and customized to who they are and where they want to go.
The most recent Common App data release (covering applications submitted between December 2023 and December 2024) offers an inside look at what’s happening right now in college admissions—and what the Class of 2026 needs to pay attention to as they finalize their list.
Here are the three most important insights every rising senior should keep in mind:
1. More Students Are Reporting Test Scores—And That Matters
There was a 9% increase in students submitting SAT or ACT scores through Common App. While some universities have reinstated testing requirements, this uptick isn’t only about policy changes. The data also reveals that students from majority backgrounds and more affluent zip codes are far more likely to report scores.
What this means for you:
If you’re from a majority background or a well-resourced school, test-optional doesn’t mean test-blind. Colleges may still favor applicants with high scores—even if they say they don’t require them. If you're not planning to submit scores, your application needs to shine in other areas, and your list must be carefully balanced with schools that truly practice test-optional admissions fairly.
At Miller College Counseling, we help every student determine whether to test, when to test, and whether to submit—based on both data and individual goals.
2. Public Universities Are More Competitive Than Ever
Applications to public universities increased by 11%, compared to just 5% at private institutions. Schools like University of Michigan, UT Austin, UNC Chapel Hill, and the UC system are becoming increasingly selective, especially for out-of-state students and those applying to programs like business, engineering, or nursing.
Strategic advice:
Don’t assume a public university is a “safety” school. For out-of-state students, they often aren’t. We help our students identify target and likely schools that truly match their academic profile—while also considering affordability, fit, and special program competitiveness.
3. Early Action Is the New Normal—but There’s a Catch
There was a 17% increase in Early Action applications this year—the most popular and competitive round yet. Many students are drawn to Early Action because it offers non-binding early consideration. But here’s the challenge: most Early Action decisions are released after Regular Decision deadlines, making it harder to adjust your list if results don’t go your way.
Miller Strategy Tip:
We guide students to include Early Action school that releases decisions before January 1. That way, you can make smart adjustments if needed.
Final Thought
A college list is more than just a collection of dream schools. It’s a strategic map. At Miller College Counseling, we’ve helped every single one of our students get accepted to college by creating lists that reflect their values, goals, academic profile, and evolving trends in admissions.
Want help crafting a college list that works for you—not just against the odds?
Book a 1:1 30 minute complimentary consultation today and let’s build your path to college success, together.
